This episode establishes the "WickedHades" ship. Reviewers from Daps Magic noted that their interaction, including a ride on Dorothy's bicycle, had "all the makings of a date" and added depth to both villains.
Rebecca Mader’s performance as Zelena received praise for balancing "unabashed evil" with her deep-seated abandonment issues. [S5E16] Our Decay
Critics and fans on platforms like Reddit often highlight this episode as a turning point for the Underworld arc, though some felt the side plots, like the "haunted phone booth," were less impactful than the central romance. Once Upon A Time S5E16 - Our Decay Review - Daps Magic This episode establishes the "WickedHades" ship