If you must see the contents, don't use "Extract All." Instead: Open your archiving tool (like WinRAR or 7-Zip) directly. Drag the file into the application window.
If you didn't ask for it, don't open it. RAR Archive File Format Family - The Library of Congress 57548.rar
The Mystery of the Archive: What to Do with Files Like "57548.rar" If you must see the contents, don't use "Extract All